:DDD again!
Feb. 1st, 2011 01:31 am![[personal profile]](https://www.dreamwidth.org/img/silk/identity/user.png){kind=small}
farlaDarthLugia is back on the recs page to continue the argument!
*** I'm sorry but in what universe is telling people to burn in hell when they disagree with her about the capitalization of Pokemon's names (when in fact the official rule by Nintendo is that they ARE capitalized, making her the one in the wrong) something necessary in the fanfic community. Honest reviews about the quality of fics (especially terrible ones) are necessary, but borderline troll reviews help no one. They just serve as a bully pulpit for her to act [[HolierThanThou Holier Than Thou]], and end up being rather unhelpful. That said, the quality of her fics is fairly good, and is worth checking out.
Followed by DialgaX saying to take it to the discussion page...as he edited it down to:
** Do note that she is ''not'' nice if not out and out rude and pushy when it comes to reviewing.
Then going to the discussion page to explain to me that
I cleaned it up because it clutters up the page.
And Farla, that does not mean I like or respect you, because I do not.
In sum, someone said my fic is good!
*** I'm sorry but in what universe is telling people to burn in hell when they disagree with her about the capitalization of Pokemon's names (when in fact the official rule by Nintendo is that they ARE capitalized, making her the one in the wrong) something necessary in the fanfic community. Honest reviews about the quality of fics (especially terrible ones) are necessary, but borderline troll reviews help no one. They just serve as a bully pulpit for her to act [[HolierThanThou Holier Than Thou]], and end up being rather unhelpful. That said, the quality of her fics is fairly good, and is worth checking out.
Followed by DialgaX saying to take it to the discussion page...as he edited it down to:
** Do note that she is ''not'' nice if not out and out rude and pushy when it comes to reviewing.
Then going to the discussion page to explain to me that
I cleaned it up because it clutters up the page.
And Farla, that does not mean I like or respect you, because I do not.
In sum, someone said my fic is good!
no subject
Date: 2011-02-01 06:38 am (UTC)Oh, I mean, nice! Someone says your fic is good!
no subject
Date: 2011-02-01 06:50 am (UTC)The first time I did this, my NaRe Q&A thread had what I thought was an obviously hyperbolic reference to telling people their story gave puppies cancer. Multiple people on the internet said I'm evil because I gave a review to their friend saying that.
This year's meme appears to be the idea that I respond at all to people trying to argue with me and do it by telling them to burn for disagreeing, despite the fact they can't see anything I'm saying via PM. I actually don't reply to PMs at all.